...The Swedish legal system anyways. The pirate bay, a Swedish run torrent hosting website has been sued by Hakan Roswell, who is filing for the USA's very own MPAA under the premise that the pirate bay has allowed over 600,000 Swedes access to illegal copies of movies.
Unlike most of the pirate bay's supporters, I do not approve of piracy. They may justify it by saying that they are fighting cooperate greed, but illegally downloading and using files you don't own is not the way to do it. My main problem in this case is the fact that the morons pushing the lawsuit are shooting the messenger. The pirate bay and torrenting works like this:
Person A goes to thepiratebay.com and uses the search function. He downloads torrent X directly from the pirate bay. He then uses a program downloaded onto his hard drive to open the torrent file. Once it is open, the torrent program will locate any other peers using the same torrent, and begin to transmit the data to person X.
Nothing about torrenting is inherently illegal, nor are the files inherently illegal. Claiming that the pirate bay is an accomplice to over 600,000 cases of copyright infringement is like claiming that the US postal service is guilty of over 100,000 cases of copyright infringement because people have mailed burned cd's to each other via the post office. The system is a completely legal and valid one, and is being used for illegal purposes, unlike something like napster, which hosted actual illegal media on its website, and gave it away. Suing the pirate bay makes about as much sense as suing google, and I know people use google to find torrents because the suggested search toolbar almost always lists +torrent after any movie title I google.
They can't sue the real criminals in this case, because the real criminals are average joes with average lives, and lawsuits would be ineffective due to the tens of millions of criminals this system has produced. Ripping a file you don't own may make you a prick and a criminal, but your actions have nothing to do with the pirate bay. They simply hold files that connect you to kind criminal pricks who are willing to send you pieces of the illegal file.
Welcome to teh intarwebs my friend, the ride get much scarier from here on in...
